Cut and Crinkled Heart** |
The man was offended by Lew's having shared his post-divorce pain as an example of broken-heartedness, or deep human suffering. The man explained that divorce, and by extension the suffering connected to divorce, reflected personal choice. "The death of a child, that's tragic," he explained.
I know that the Jewish High Holy Day season is much concerned with judgment, but is the legitimacy of a person's claim to having a broken heart something to be judged? The Alan Lew critic seemed to be suggesting that only the suffering connected with tragic--terrible and unchosen--events merited our heartfelt compassion, that anything short of that was less worthy of our sincerest sympathies.
I knew immediately that I disagreed with him.
All of this especially matters during this Jewish penitential season because the Jewish sages speak explicitly about broken hearts. “'There is nothing as whole as a broken heart,' said the Kotsker Rebbe (rabbi, 1787-1859)."**** And when Rabbi Simon Jacobson reiteraties this teaching--he actually uses the word "complete" to describe a broken heart--and then enumerates some potential sources of broken-heartedness, he does not rank them in any way:
Jacobson's hope is that the communal and individual meditations, prayers, and practices central to the Jewish High Holy Days will both console and effect the healing of people's broken hearts: "The reality is the world is a broken place--it's a broken place full of broken people whose job it is to mend what is broken."***** (52)"We all make mistakes and break things in our life, but life also breaks us. We've all been broken in one way or another. We have all experienced broken promises or broken relationships; we have all experienced the loss of a job or the loss of a loved one."***** (52)
by Scott Ketcham******
I hope so, too, because looking back over this past year, I recognize that I've been wandering through a garden of breaking and broken hearts. So many whom I know have lost loved ones this year. Others are continuing to walk beside those who are expected to die soon. Yet others are still grieving those who died in recent years. And then there are those whose hearts have been broken not by death, but by life: lost love, job challenges and disappointments, health challenges, the understanding that certain problems can't be solved and will only get worse. Others have been mourning a loss of identity, direction, and purpose.
In addition, for many, the experience of inhabiting a world in which so many--sometimes, even we ourselves--suffer routinely as a result of the willful exclusion, harassment, and neglect perpetrated by powerful others is another source of sadness. I hesitate to call it brokenness since so many who fight against injustice also fight against being characterized as broken. But when thwarted efforts to fight injustice and make positive change combine with other sources of anger and discouragement, the weight they collectively place on hearts can be straining if not breaking.
I've had my own sadnesses this year, and the sum of them on occasion has made my world far darker than usual. No, I haven't felt the broken-heartedness of someone who daily looks at an empty chair at the dinner table or into an empty bedroom at the end of the hallway. But there have been times when combinations of feelings--grief over the loss of a dear friend last winter (reignited the other day when I received a Facebook friendship request from him--OMG, Facebook hackers!!!!!); uncertainty about my ability to be both a responsible and a loving daughter to my nonagenarian parents; worries about other important people in my life who've been struggling not to become completely physically and emotionally depleted by the health, career, relationship, and familial demands of their lives; fears that I'm really "not doing anything"--or at least not doing enough--with my "skills and talents"--without any accompanying insights into what I should be doing with them--have made my heart feel heavy to the point of breaking.
I think the man I spoke about at the beginning of this blog post would probably chide me for speaking of my sadness this way. But Simon Jacobson and Alan Lew would no doubt go easier on me. Neither man would advocate denying pain: Lew, whose Judaism often reflects his Buddhist spiritual roots, explains, "Getting into the habit of embracing our pain can be the first step toward getting past it by moving from the melodrama of suffering and affliction to a more pleasurable and primary world of impulse, energy, and sensation" (Be Still, 83).******* Jacobson says, "When your heart is broken, you are in a place that is real."*****
The first time, I was up in the middle of the night worrying, worrying, worrying, convinced that what lay ahead of me was a great deal of busyness that would ultimately benefit neither my parents, nor my husband, nor my colleagues, nor me. Overwhelmed by this sense, I stopped fighting it, and said to myself, "You are so sad." Suddenly my whole body relaxed, and I began breathing deeply. I hadn't decided to breathe deeply; I just started breathing deeply. I realized I hadn't felt relaxed for the longest time because in that moment, I was actually feeling at peace. Nothing about my world had changed, but somehow I felt held, like I had a chance.
Breathing Woman Atop "Bouffants and Broken Hearts" *(9) |
Teshuvah, whether defined as repentance, an accounting of the spirit, a turning, or a return to God and/or one's divine essence, requires effort and compassion both. As Lew says, "Our suffering, the unresolved elements of our lives is also from God. It is the instrument by which we are carried back to God, not something to be defended against, but rather to embraced" (This is Real, 63).
Philosophically, I agree with this, but I imagine this offers little or no comfort to those who can hardly breathe at all because they've been crying so much and so hard. They don't need to be reminded to embrace their suffering because they viscerally as well as emotionally can't escape it even for a minute.
So at this moment at this time of year, I have two wishes.
The first is that all those suffering deeply, all those who can't seem to find even a single moment when they're not mired in darkness and pain, find some peace, whatever its source might be. And the second is that all of us who suffer less acutely--but who suffer nonetheless--most of the rest of us--respond to our own and others' suffering with compassion and acceptance, and even love. And yes, I say this, knowing, as you probably do, a few people who seem to like nothing better than to elicit our and others' sympathies, which requires them to present themselves regularly as suffering; and yes, it's annoying. But even so.
Broken Heart on a Brick Wall *(10) |
* Lew, A. (2018). This is real and you are completely unprepared: The Days of Awe as a journey of transformation. New York: Back Bay Books/Little, Brown and Company.
** Cut and Crinkled Heart: https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2017/11/16/10/istock-533477557.jpg*** While Lew doesn't characterize himself as a narcissist, he does say in one of his books that he has a certain kind of nervy authority, a kind of shadow self that he's not all that proud of, but that allows him to write books in the first place.
**** Kukla, E. R. (n.d.). Wholeness of a Broken Heart [Web log post]. Retrieved September 17, 2019, from https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/wholeness-of-a-broken-heart/
***** Jacobson, S. (2008). 60 Days: A Spiritual guide to the high holidays. 2nd revised ed. New York: Kiyum.
*(6) "The Man Who Swallowed a Bird" by Scott Ketcham: https://www.scottketcham.com/post/132767564002/379-the-man-who-swallowed-a-bird-2015-28-x-19
*(7) Lew, A. (2005). Be still and get going: A Jewish meditation practice for real life. New York: Little, Brown and Co.
*(8) Image found at https://www.bing.com/images/search?view=detailV2&id=7FAF9C408758F68993F23060CDC772FC903D6959&thid=OIP.bVJAVfZHuNlg7ujK2xXdhwHaEK&mediaurl=http%3A%2F%2Fi39.tinypic.com%2F25z1ojo.jpg&exph=450&expw=800&q=dark+bedroom+at+night&selectedindex=77&ajaxhist=0&vt=0&eim=0
*(9) Clipart (Relaxation Techniques Clipart Woman atop "Bouffants and Broken Hearts" from the blog by the same name at
https://www.bouffantsandbrokenhearts.com/; Garden Bits can be found at
this address:https://www.bouffantsandbrokenhearts.com/post/76604966511/garden-bits*(10) Screen shot of http://home.bt.com/images/is-a-broken-heart-as-bad-for-you-as-a-heart-attack-136422807691602601-171113143931.jpg
Just found this, Joan and it filled my heart.Bless you. j
ReplyDelete