I'd like to hear from you about it. Specifically, I'd love to know about any piece of it--or even about the whole of it--any of following:
- what it makes you think, and/or
- what it makes you wonder, and/or
- what it makes you feel, and/or
- what you think works, and/or
- what you think doesn't work, and/or
- anything else.
I think there are some verb tense problems, too.
So first I'll present the poem; and then I'll tell you where you can respond: there are several places and ways. Ideally, I'd like you to be able to see others' responses, but I'm happy for your name not to accompany your comments, if you'd like to respond anonymously.
Here goes!
Eden in Lockdown
"Eden is that old-fashioned House
We dwell in every day . . .."*
Emily Dickinson
We hadn't known we were in Eden
'Til we learned we couldn't leave it.
But we had time on our hands,
Something we seldom did,
Something we seldom took into our hands
When the choice was ours.
So what to take into our hands,
Given the perils of touch itself,
What to shape to our most
Private self or public need
When dreams deferred so oft to fear
Since what happens next
Is in all our hands?
I started with meatloaf
On the evening of the first day--
And it was good.
On the morning of the second day,
I bundled newspapers for recycling,
Wrote checks and birthday cards,
Filed clippings in folders where I'd never look.
I told myself what was still good:
Spring just days away,
Robins flocking to the neighbor's hedge,
Electricity surging through power lines,
Keeping us warm and and within reach,
Softening exile at the edge of the unknown.
Best to be placed on house arrest
When one calls someplace home.
On the third night, when the March wind
Silenced the whispers of spring,
I thought of those sentenced to the streets
For whom Eden might be memory,
mockery, or myth.
Okay, if you want to respond to this poem and can leave a comment below (I know some of you have lost comments trying to do this in the past), please do so. If you respond on my Facebook page, I will copy your comments into the comment section below. And if you prefer to email me your comment, I will also post it below.
Also, if you're a "See-Think-Wonder" thinking routine*** fan from our shared or not shared Project Zero days, feel free to respond using that format.
Above all, stay safe and well! Take lots of soap into those hands that you have time on! Thank you for reading and responding, should you choose to. And looking forward to seeing you in the spring.
* Emily Dickinson, CVIII from Part Five, The Single Hound.
** Black, C. (2008). "And God separated the light from the dark" [Cartoon]. Winnipeg Free Press.
*** Ritchhart, Church, M., & Morrison, K. (2011). Making thinking visible: How to promote engagement, understanding, and independence for all learners. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
A revision:
ReplyDeleteSo what to take into our hands,
Given the perils of touch itself,
What to shape to our most
Private self or public need
When dreams defer so fast to fear
Since private and public,
Separate but inseparable,
Plant what's next in our hands?
Is in all our hands?
Forget the last line above:
DeleteSo what to take into our hands,
Given the perils of touch itself,
What to shape to our most
Private self or public need
When dreams defer so fast to fear
Since private and public,
Separate but inseparable,
Plant the near future
Firm in our hands?
Yes, “oft” was jarring in the context of the vocabulary of this poem.
DeleteI loved “first day/second day/it was good” and would love a better sense of what’s being created.
Hi,lspieler--I also struggled with "oft." I can't thank you enough for your second comment--it's cluing me in to exactly what I need to be thinking about as I revise. No answers yet!
DeleteA comment from an anonymous friend:
ReplyDeleteYour poem makes me think we took our home, our Eden for granted.
We cannot touch each other, but now we have time in our hands. (I will mop my bathroom tomorrow in addition to reading students' papers.)
Most importantly, your poem reminds us that some do not have a shelter or an Eden. What do they do? Homelessness and this virus: what is happening to the homeless? You eloquently put it as those "sentenced to the streets."
I also found the section on the "dream deferred" and what "is...in our hands" powerful.
A comment from another friend, who emailed me:
ReplyDeleteYour poem reminded me, as well as it did others, what a lovely "Eden" I do have here. I have everything I need for quite a while and the video calls can feel close to in-person conversations. I, too, worry about those who have little or no resources, the homeless, those in prisons. I must also admit that I was feeling a bit smug, I think: I had checked off all the boxes on all those lists and thought I was calm about it all. But I had a nightmare last night that made me admit that I have been worried, too. Back to feeling so grateful to those who are checking in...
The first two stanzas of your poem have a wonderful flow and rhythm. I saw your revision this morning, replacing the word "oft" with "fast." I LIKE it! But I also like the original last lines of the 2nd stanza: Since what happens next/Is in all our hands. I like them because they continue the wonderful rhythm of the first stanzas. The 3rd stanza departs from the rhythm, then returns in the 4th... So my wondering is, how might the rhythms help to push the emotions in the poem?
BTW, I don't think there are too many allusions; they work for me. Footnotes...hummm. I think I can identify the allusions, but I might be mis-remembering. I can't decide if it would be a nice link to other writers or not really necessary. Right now, I think I want to see if I'm right about the Eden poem!
"So my wondering is, how might the rhythms help to push the emotions in the poem?" A great question for me to wrestle with as I revise this poem in preparation for my poetry-writing group's Zoom meeting on Friday! Thanks, anonymous friend!
Delete